The Rebranded NAFTA: Will the USMCA Achieve the Goals of the Trump Administration for North American Trade?

  • Robert A. Blecker

Abstract

The United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (usmca) was the product of a renegotiation of the former North American Free Trade Agreement (nafta) that was intended by the Trump administration to “put America first.” This article analyzes the most important new provisions in the usmca that that administration believed would inhibit foreign investment in Mexico and reverse the offshoring of U.S. jobs. Some of the new provisions represent improvements over nafta, especially the limitations on investor-state dispute settlement and strengthened protections for labor rights. However, the new requirements for automobile production are likely    to backfire by making North American automotive production more expensive and less competitive. On the whole, the formation of the usmca probably enhanced, rather than lessened, the confidence of foreign investors in the Mexican economy. However, the agreement is unlikely to bring about large gains in U.S. manufacturing employment or to boost the long-run growth of the Mexican economy.

References

ARTECONA, RAQUEL, AND DANIEL PERROTTI. 2021.
2021 “Latin American and the Caribbean exports to the United States: Analysis of the competition with China and other regions at product level, 2002- 2018,” Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC), Washington Office, United Nations publication no. LC/WAS/TS.2021/06.

ASAYAMA, RYO, AND SOTARO YUMAE
2020 “US OR MEXICO? JAPAN’S AUTO INDUSTRY TORN OVER USMCA,” NIKKEI BUSINESS, JULY 16.

ASSOCIATED PRESS
2021 “MEXICO ANNOUNCES STEPS TO ENSURE FREE UNION VOTE AT GM PLANT,”
THE WASHINGTON POST, JULY 8.

AUTOR, DAVID H., DAVID DORN, AND GORDON H. HANSON
2016 “THE CHINA SHOCK: LEARNING FROM LABOR-MARKET ADJUSTMENT TO LARGE CHANGES IN TRADE,” ANNUAL REVIEW OF ECONOMICS, VOL. 8, PP. 205-240.

BIVENS, JOSH
2017 ADDING INSULT TO INJURY: HOW BAD POLICY DECISIONS HAVE AMPLIFIED GLOBALIZATION’S COSTS FOR AMERICAN WORKERS, WASHINGTON, D.C., ECONOMIC POLICY INSTITUTE.

BLECKER, ROBERT A.
2021 “Mexico: Unequal Integration and ‘Stabilizing Stagnation,’” in L. Randall Wray and Flavia Dantas, eds., Handbook of Economic Stagnation, Amsterdam, Elsevier, forthcoming.

2019 “NAFTA,” in Robert E. Looney, ed., Handbook of International Trade Agreements: Country, Regional and Global Approaches, Abingdon, UK, Routledge, pp. 147-165.

2016 “Integration, Productivity, and Inclusion in Mexico: A Macro Perspective,” in Alejandro Foxley and Barbara Stallings, eds., Innovation and Inclusion in Latin America: Strategies to Avoid the Middle Income Trap, New York, Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 175-204.

2014 “The Mexican and U.S. Economies after Twenty Years of NAFTA,”
International Journal of Political Economy, vol. 43, no. 2, pp. 5-26.

BLECKER, ROBERT A., and GERARDO ESQUIVEL
2013 “Trade and the Development Gap,” in Andrew Selee and Peter Smith, eds., Mexico and the United States: The Politics of Partnership, Boulder, Colorado, Lynne Rienner, pp. 83-110.

BLECKER, ROBERT A., JUAN CARLOS MORENO-BRID, and ISABEL SALAT
2021 “What Policies Make Sense in a U.S.-Mexico Trade Deal?” in Raúl Hinojosa-Ojeda and Edward Telles, eds., The Trump Paradox: Migration, Trade, and Racial Politics in U.S.-Mexico Integration, Oakland, University of California Press, pp. 174-188.

BLS (BUREAU OF LABOR STATISTICS)
2021 “Employment, Hours, and Earnings from the Current Employment Statistics Survey (National),” https://www.bls.gov/ces/data/, accessed June 30, 2021.

BOARD OF GOVERNORS OF THE FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM
2021 G.17 - Industrial Production and Capacity Utilization for June 15, 2021, Base Year 2017, Industrial Production Index for Manufacturing, North American Industrial Classification System (NAICS), https://www.federalreserve.gov/data.htm, accessed July 8, 2021.

Borraz, Fernando, and José Ernesto López-Cordova
2007 “Has globalization deepened income inequality in Mexico?” in Global Economy Journal, vol. 7, issue 1, article 6. https://doi.org/10.2202/1524-5861.1237

Boundi Chraki, Fahd.
2017 “Análisis insumo-producto multirregional e integración económica del TLCAN. Una aplicación del método de extracción hipotética,” in Cuadernos de Economía, vol. 40, no. 114, pp. 256-267. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cesjef.2016.10.004

BOLIO, EDUARDO, JAANA REMES, TOMÁS LAJOUS, JAMES MANYIKA, EUGENIA RAMIREZ, and MORTEN ROSSÉ
2014 A Tale of Two Mexicos: Growth and Prosperity in a Two-speed Economy, San Francisco, McKinsey Global Institute.
BURFISHER, MARY E., FREDERIC LAMBERT, and TROY MATHESON
2019 “NAFTA to USMCA: What Is Gained?” Washington, D.C., International Monetary Fund (IMF), Working Paper WP/19/73, March.
CALIENDO, LORENZO, and FERNANDO PARRO
2015 “Estimates of the Trade and Welfare Effects of NAFTA,” Review of Economic Studies, vol. 82, no. 1, pp. 1-44.

CIURIAK, DAN
2019 “From NAFTA to USMCA and the Evolution of U.S. Trade Policy,” Toronto, C.D. Howe Institute / Verbatim, June 25.

CIURIAK, DAN, ALI DADKHAH, and JINGLIANG XIAO
2019 “Quantifying CUSMA: The Economic Consequences of the New North American Trade Regime,” Toronto, C.D. Howe Institute, Working Paper, July 25.

CIURIAK, DAN, and ROBERT FAY
2021 “The USMCA and Mexico’s Prospects under the New North American Trade Regime,” in Aliza Chelminsky, Bernadette G. Vega Sánchez, and Jorge O. Armijo de la Garza, eds., Implementing the USMCA: A Test for North America, Mexico City, Senado de la República, January, pp. 45-66.

CROWLEY, MEREDITH, and DAN CIURIAK
2018 “Weaponizing Uncertainty,” Toronto, C.D. Howe Institute / Verbatim, June 19.

DARVAS, ZSOLT
2012 “Real Effective Exchange Rates for 178 Countries: A New Database,” Working Paper 2012/06, Bruegel, March 15; Last update, June 15, 2021, https://www.bruegel.org/publications/datasets/real-effective-exchange-rates-for-178-countries-a- new-database/, accessed July 11, 2021.

DE LOECKER, JAN, JAN EECKHOUT, and GABRIEL UNGER
2020 “The Rise of Market Power and the Macroeconomic Implications,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 135, no. 2, pp. 561-644.

DÍAZ BAUTISTA, ALEJANDRO
2017 “Total Factor Productivity (TFP) in Manufacturing and Economic Growth in Mexico,” Análisis Económico, vol. 23, no. 79, January-April, pp. 7-24.

DUSSEL PETERS, ENRIQUE, and KEVIN P. GALLAGHER
2013 “NAFTA’s Uninvited Guest: China and the Disintegration of North American Trade,” CEPAL Review, no. 110, pp. 83-108.


EL FINANCIERO
2021 “EU gana primera batalla del T-MEC: mexicana Tridonex pagará salarios a trabajadores despedidos,” El Financiero, August 10.

ELSBY, MICHAEL, BART HOBIJN, and AYŞEGÜL ŞAHIN
2013 “The Decline of the U.S. Labor Share,” Brookings Papers on Economic Analysis, spring, pp. 1-52.

ESCAITH, HUBERT
2021 “From NAFTA to USMCA: Can a Good Idea that Came Too Late Be Born Again?” draft paper for this Dossier in Norteamérica, vol. 16, no. 2.

ESQUIVEL, GERARDO
2015 Extreme Inequality in Mexico, Mexico City, Oxfam (Oxford Committee for Famine Relief).

ESQUIVEL, GERARDO, and JOSÉ ANTONIO RODRÍGUEZ-LÓPEZ
2003 “Technology, Trade, and Wage Inequality in Mexico Before and After NAFTA,” Journal of Development Economics, vol. 72, no. 2, pp. 543-65.

FEENSTRA, ROBERT C., and GORDON H. HANSON
1997 “Foreign Direct Investment and Relative Wages: Evidence from Mexico’s Maquiladoras,” Journal of International Economics, vol. 42, nos. 3-4, pp. 371-94.

FEENSTRA, ROBERT C., and HIAO LOOI KEE
2009 “Trade Liberalization and Export Variety: A Comparison of Mexico and China,” in Daniel Lederman, Marcelo Olarreaga, and Guillermo E. Perry, eds., China’s and India’s Challenge to Latin America: Opportunity or Threat? Washington, D.C., World Bank, pp. 145-78.

FICKLING, DAVID, and ANJANI TRIVEDI
2018 “Trump’s Mexico Trade Deal Looks Like a Lemon,” Bloomberg, August 28, https://www.bloombergquint.com/gadfly/trump-s-mexico-trade-deal-looks-like-a-lemon

GALLAGHER, KEVIN P., JUAN CARLOS MORENO-BRID, and ROBERTO PORZECANSKI
2008 “The Dynamism of Mexican Exports: Lost in (Chinese) Translation?” World Development, vol. 36, no. 8, pp. 1365-1380.

GARSTEN, ED
2020 “USMCA Trade Deal Is Now in Force—And Mandating Higher Wages, More Paperwork,” Forbes, July 1.

GONZÁLEZ, FRANCISCO E.
2019 Mexico Under Misplaced Monopolies: Concentrated Wealth and Growing Violence from the 1980s to the Present, New York, Routledge.

GUERRERO, ISABEL, LUIS FELIPE LOPEZ-CALVA, and MICHAEL WALTON
2009 “The Inequality Trap and Its Links to Low Growth in Mexico,” in Santiago Levy and Michael Walton, eds., No Growth Without Equity? Inequality, Interests, and Competition in Mexico, Washington, D.C., World Bank, pp. 111-156.

HAKOBYAN, SUSHANIK, and JOHN MCLAREN
2016 “Looking for Local Labor Market Effects of NAFTA,” Review of Economics and Statistics, vol. 98, no. 4, pp. 728-741.

HANSON, GORDON H.
2010 “Why Isn’t Mexico Rich?” Journal of Economic Literature, vol. 48, no. 4, pp. 987- 1004.

2004 “What Has Happened to Wages in Mexico since NAFTA? Implications f or Hemispheric Free Trade,” in Antoni Estevadeordal, Dani Rodrik, Alan M. Taylor, and Andres Velasco, eds., Integrating the Americas: FTAA and Beyond, Cambridge, Harvard University Press, pp. 505-37.

HANSON, GORDON H., and RAYMOND ROBERTSON
2009 “China and the Recent Evolution of Latin America’s Manufacturing Exports,” in Daniel Lederman, Marcelo Olarreaga, and Guillermo E. Perry, eds., China’s and India’s Challenge to Latin America: Opportunity or Threat? Washington, D.C., World Bank, pp. 245-63.

HERNANDEZ-TRILLO, FAUSTO.
2018. “Mexico, NAFTA, and beyond,” in The International Trade Journal, vol. 32, no. 1, pp. 5-20.

HUERTA, ARTURO
2021 “The Stagnation of the Mexican Economy Is Here to Stay,” in L. Randall Wray and Flavia Dantas, eds., Handbook of Economic Stagnation, Amsterdam, Elsevier, forthcoming.

IBARRA, CARLOS A., and JAIME ROS
2019 “The Decline of the Labor Income Share in Mexico, 1990- 2015,” World Development, vol. 122, October, pp. 570-84.

IMF (INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND)
2021a International Financial Statistics, online database, https://www.imf.org/en/Data, accessed July 16, 2021.

2021b World Economic Outlook Database, April 2021 edition, https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WEO/weo-database/2021/April, accessed July 9, 2021.

INEGI (INSTITUTO NACIONAL DE ESTADÍSTICA Y GEOGRAFÍA)
2019 Censos económicos 2019, https://www.inegi.org.mx/programas/ce/2019/, accessed July 10, 2021.

2007-2019 Encuesta mensual de la industria manufacturera (EMIM), Base 2008 for 2007-2013 and Base 2013 for 2013-2019, https://www.inegi.org.mx/app/indicadores/bie.html, accessed June 26, 2021.

n. d. Indicadores económicos de coyuntura, Actividad industrial, base 2013, total industrias manufactureras, https://www.inegi.org.mx/app/indicadores/bie.html, accessed July 8, 2021.

INSIDE U.S. TRADE
2019 “Labor Reform Debate Heats up in Mexican Congress; USMCA Compliance in Question,” March 22.

LEVY, SANTIAGO
2018 Under-Rewarded Efforts: The Elusive Quest for Prosperity in Mexico, Washington, D.C., Inter-American Development Bank (IDB).

LÓPEZ, JULIO
2018 “Growth Dilemmas in Open Middle-income Economies: A Reflection on Mexico’s Recent Experience,” Review of Keynesian Economics, vol. 6, no. 3, pp. 333-351.

LYNCH, DAVID J.
2021 “White House Calls on Mexican Government to Probe Possible Labor Violations at GM Auto Plant,” The Washington Post, May 12.

MILLER, SCOTT
2018 “Investor-state Dispute Settlement Faces Hurdles on the Road Ahead,” Saigon, Hinrich Foundation, May 10.

MISHEL, LAWRENCE, and JOSH BIVENS
2021 Identifying the Policy Levers Generating Wage Suppression and Wage Inequality, Washington, D.C., Economic Policy Institute.

MORALES, ROBERTO
2021 “EU complica a México regla de origen laboral en el T-MEC,” El Economista, July 19.

MORENO-BRID, JUAN CARLOS, and JAIME ROS
2009 Development and Growth in the Mexican Economy: A Historical Perspective, New York, Oxford University Press.

NAKAYAMA, SHUJI, and RYO ASAYAMA
2020 “Japan Auto Companies Triple Mexican Pay Rather than Move to U.S.,” Nikkei Business, June 28.

NICITA, ALESSANDRO
2009 “The Price Effect of Tariff Liberalization: Measuring the Impact on
Household Welfare,” Journal of Development Economics, vol. 89, no. 1, pp. 19-27.

PUBLIC CITIZEN
2021 “Ending the Corporate Power Grab of Investor-State Dispute Settlement,” https://www.citizen.org/topic/globalization-trade/corporate-power-expanded-isds/, accessed July 13, 2021.

2018 “What Does NAFTA 2.0 Mean for Investor-State Dispute Settlement?” Global Trade Watch, October 12, https://www.citizen.org/article/more-information- on-investor-state-dispute-settlement/, accessed July 13, 2021.

REVENGA, ANA L., and CLAUDIO E. MONTENEGRO
1998 “North American Integration and Factor price Equalization: Is There Evidence of Wage Convergence between Mexico and the United States?” in Susan M. Collins, ed., Imports, Exports, and the American Worker, Washington, D.C., Brookings Institution, pp. 305-47.

RODRÍGUEZ, IVET
2021 “El sindicato de la CTM pierde en la consulta de la planta de GM en Silao,” in Expansión, August 19, 2021.

ROMALIS, JOHN
2007 “NAFTA’s and CUSFTA’s Impact on International Trade,” Review of Economics and Statistics, vol. 89, no. 3, pp. 416-435.

ROS BOSCH, JAIME
2013 Algunas tesis equivocadas sobre el estancamiento económico de México, Mexico City, El Colegio de México /Dirección General de Publicaciones y Fomento Editorial (DGPyFE)-UNAM.

SALDAÑA, IVETTE
2021 “EU advierte que creará panel laboral si México no cumple con compromisos del T-MEC,” El Universal, June 29.

SÁNCHEZ, AXEL
2021 “T-MEC: México tiene récord histórico de exportación de autopartes,” El Financiero,” July 19.

STANSBURY, ANNA, and LAWRENCE H. SUMMERS
2020 “The Declining Worker Power Hypothesis: An Explanation for the Recent Evolution of the American Economy,” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Spring, pp. 1-77.

STUART, OWEN
2018 “How Will the Shift from NAFTA to USMCA Affect the Auto Industry?”
Industry Week, October 12.

TREFLER, DANIEL
2004 “The Long and Short of the Canada-U.S. Free Trade Agreement,”
American Economic Review, vol. 94, no. 4, pp. 870-95.

USITC (U.S. INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION)
2019 U.S.-Mexico-Canada Trade Agreement: Likely Impact on the U.S. Economy and on Specific Industry Sectors (with errata), Washington, D.C., USITC Publication no. 4889, April.

USLA, HÉCTOR
2021 “Ven crecimiento de México en 2021 de 6.5% por T-MEC,” El Financiero, July 8.

VERHOOGEN, ERIC A.
2008 “Trade, Quality Upgrading, and Wage Inequality in the Mexican Manufacturing Sector,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 123, no. 2, pp. 489-530.

WALMSLEY, TERRIE, AND PETER MINOR
2017 “Reversing NAFTA: A supply chain perspective,” ImpactECON working paper 007 REV-2, revised, October.
Published
2021-11-18
How to Cite
Blecker, R. (2021). The Rebranded NAFTA: Will the USMCA Achieve the Goals of the Trump Administration for North American Trade?. Norteamérica, Revista Académica Del CISAN-UNAM, 16(2). https://doi.org/10.22201/cisan.24487228e.2021.2.516
Section
DOSSIER